31 May 2012

UKSG Usage Statistics Training Seminar / DCU - 30th May 2012

This training seminar represented a hands-on introduction to accessing, collating, utilising, presenting and marketing e-resource usage statistics. The focus very much revolved around COUNTER-compliant e-resource usage data.  

Counting Online Usage of Networked Electronic Resources is an international initiative serving librarians, publishers and intermediaries by setting standards that facilitate the recording and reporting of online usage statistics in a consistent, credible and compatible way. For a full list of COUNTER-Code-of-Practice compliant vendors refer to the register of vendors (Journals and Databases; e-books and reference works).

The COUNTER Code of Practice Release 4 is scheduled for December 2013.
For the full list of relevant Release 4 e-resource usage reports refer to Table 1 in the step-by-step guide for vendors.

To make the job easier, COUNTER reports can be harvested via SUSHI. For more information refer to niso.org. JISC offers a 'beginners', free, open source programme with a web-based user interface to support the downloading/retrieval of COUNTER-compliant SUSHI reports.

The morning session tackled the publisher (IOP Publishing) and library perspective (TCD) on the importance of e-resource usage data for information providers. Publishers use usage data to inform their editorial strategy, understand their user base (site design, measure effectiveness of technological change, understand discoverability and understand usage abuse), as well as their sales and marketing strategy.

Libraries employ quantitative e-resource usage data in order to:
  • evidence e-resource use
  • demonstrate value for money
  • help justify expenditure on a resource
  • benchmark
  • inform collection development decisions (which to cancel/retain)
  • influence subscription management processes
Key metrics include:
  • cost per use (total cost divided by total no. of searchers' downloads)
  • use/cost per staff/student
  • journal collections performance
  • top performing titles
  • resource performance by type (e.g. e-journals, e-books, databases) and discipline
  • types of use (on campus vs. off campus)

A representative from JUSP (Journal Usage Statistics Portal) introduced their role and service scope. JUSP is a usage statistics service provider, i.e. a "one-stop shop" for libraries to view, download and analyse their usage reports from NESLi2.

The following challenges in collating and utilising e-resouces statistics apply:
  • Meaningful analysis and collation of usage statistics is labour intensive
  • Merging/filtering COUNTER-compliant and non-compliant e-resource usage reports can be challenging (many vendors are still not COUNTER compliant; examples include Justis/Firstlaw, Financial Times, WARC etc.)
It must be noted that usage statistics do not say anything meaningful about teaching and learning.
Also, quantitative usage statistics should never be considered in isolation of qualitative feedback from users. In this sense, e-resource related management decision making is not an exact (number crunching) science.

After a good coffee-and-sandwich lunch, the practical element of the training kicked in. This was, from my perspective, very useful.

We were given a workbook (feel free to use it yourself) and a selection of dummy COUNTER reports to play with (go ahead and use those too):
Overall, the training represented an interesting peek into the world of retrieving and managing e-resource usage data.

29 May 2012

The New Professional’s Toolkit - Bethan Ruddock (Review)

What is initially most refreshing about The New Professional’s Toolkit, is that instead of starting off with traditional ‘librarian’ topics such as Collection Development or Reference Services, chapter one delves straight into project management. Indeed from a cursory glance down the table of contents (or even the title itself where there is a notable lack of any reference to libraries or information), this could be a book about any number of professions; there are chapters on teaching, training & communicating, measuring performance, marketing your services, using technologies, networking & promoting yourself, and managing budgets. Whilst the content of the toolkit is always applied to the library and information setting, it emanates from a best-practice management context – something that is often lacking in books aimed at new entrants to the profession.

Not that there are in fact many such books, which is largely the USP of Ruddock's book; it neatly bridges the gap between college texts and more specialised in-depth monographs. Consequently, the tone of the book is very much underpinned by a pragmatic ‘tips & tricks’ approach, yet not in a lightweight or superficial sense. The result is a text that is very easy to dip in and out of as a reference source, and to find further references, useful websites and other resources for use in practice. You won’t find lengthy narratives or detailed information here, but rather short paragraphs and bullet points – exactly what you want in a toolkit. The recurrent focus on self-study and informal learning in the workplace in particularly valuable. For example, Ruddock emphasises that much of the theory and principles of topics like project management, budgeting or marketing which are taught through formal training courses, can also be learned by self-study using free online resources and websites, including those listed in the toolkit. It is a creative approach, and one that is particularly relevant in these times of rationalised training budgets.

The chapter on marketing services and engaging stakeholders is particularly well-focused. Here Ruddock discusses the advantages of pursuing a benefit-led approach: it’s no good telling people you have access to a new database, instead inform your users (and indeed more importantly your non-users!) how it will make their job easier or better, or how it will improve their research. Essentially, demonstrate to them how your services are directly relevant and of value to them as an individual. Ruddock also raises ideas such as the importance of timing your promotional activities, ‘engaging with the disengaged’ and using an embedded librarianship approach within an organisation to help build stronger relationships.

The chapter on technology is perhaps a little lightweight and formative for those seeking more advanced assistance however, and readers would likely be familiar with most if not all of the content from prior study. Indeed at just over two hundred pages in total, there is still significant scope for being a little more comprehensive in places, without it becoming a turgid task to plough through for the time-pressed reader. Furthermore, it was disappointing not to see any real advice in terms of writing annual reports or library policies, as many new professionals may have limited, if indeed any, experience in this regard.

The idea of a new librarian’s toolkit that is first and foremost about how to manage effectively rather than ‘how to do library stuff’ is timely and extremely welcome. The need to step outside the profession to borrow from and integrate best practice and ideas from other disciplines such as project management, marketing and I.T. is essential – even for new professionals - and Ruddock clearly recognises this. However most importantly perhaps given its target audience, The New Professionals Toolkit doesn’t drag you down a side-path of digressive background-reading, but instead makes you want to actually get on with the job.


The New Professional's Toolkit by Bethan Ruddock is published by Facet (May 2012; 192pp; paperback; 978-1-85604-768-5; £44.95)

28 May 2012

What can be done about the impermanence of the web?

Up until very recently we stored our pictures, documents and other treasured personal momentoes in photo albums, folders or, in more recent times, on hard drives and external portable hard drives. These days, many people are increasingly storing these items online using pay services such as Dropbox, Google Drive, Ubuntu One and many more. But what happens if you upload some of your personal files or writing onto a website for free and that website no longer exists or the company decides to delete it? Jason Scott and his Archive Team describe themselves as a "loose collective of rogue archivists, programmers, writers and loudmouths" who are "dedicated to saving our digital heritage".

They hear about failing websites and rush in to salvage what they can before user content is deleted and lost forever. They don't not seek permission from the site owners and generally only try to save files that are publicly available. They use the analogy of a library service closing down and burning all the stock to explain what they see as the reckless vandalism of the internet operators:

"It's like going into the library business and deciding, 'This is not working for us anymore,' and burning down the library."
People tend to believe that anything they submit to the web will be kept safe by the various web operators. Vast amounts of data have been lost due to changes in ownership, attacks by hackers and abrupt shutdowns of services. GeoCities was closed down by Yahoo in 2009, resulting in the loss of 38 million homemade pages.


The Archive Team saved what it could salvage from GeoCities as well as Poetry.com, Flip.com and Friendster.Some people may be aware of the Wayback Machine, operated by the Independent Archive. This service allows users to see archived versions of web pages over time. Scott is an employee of the Independent Archive but operates the Archive Team independently.

Scott maintains that apparently silly or throwaway content found on sites like GeoCities can have unanticipated cultural value. Geocities was for many people their first experience in uploading content to the web and much of value may have been deleted when Yahoo pulled the plug on the service. Scott is deeply skeptical of sites like Facebook, Flickr and Google. Google has already withdrawn support for Google labs, a site dedicated to experimental projects. He makes the salient point that free services simply cannot be relied upon to store your data in the Cloud.

It makes sense for us to not be limited to one company for the data we store online. There are signs that companies are opening up from their proprietary policies and making it easy for us to switch to competitors' products. Google Takeaway allows users to export their files easily. Facebook also has a "Download a Copy" function for the photos and other content users have on the site.


Ultimately, it seems that we ourselves need to take responsiblity for backing up our important data in a number of places. We simply cannot rely on free service providers on the web to save it for us. Just as information has died in the past-such as books going out of print-so it will continue to do so if users do not take steps to store it properly. Perhaps the Archive Team may be better served in educating internet users about potential loss of files and what they can do to avoid this. Perhaps those external hard drives and photo albums weren't so old fashioned after all.

27 May 2012

This business of tracking library usage…

…is challenging and time consuming. We all want to understand what our respective audiences are up to. Collecting realistic usage data should be easy and swift without taking up too much individual staff time.

The basics revolve around finding out about:
  • Nature and frequency of assistance we provide
  • What are our busiest hours (by the hour/daily/weekly/monthly)?
  • How do our busiest hours change over the semester?
  • Identify reference staff training needs based on patrons’ FAQs
  • Sources of reference questions (e.g. phone, in person, IM, email)
  • Effective staffing patterns
  • Collection development needs

Libraries want to access this information in a timely and efficient manner. The mechanism of collecting stats must be simple. Reports from raw data should be compiled easily too. There’s libstats and desktracker.

You could also enter data into a spreadsheet from a form via Google Docs.
  • Simple data recording (minimise clicks via a grid of check-box options)
  • Instant stats compilation
  • Easy export to Excel
  • Quick customisation
  • Expandability (tracking variables)
  • Web accessibility
  • Built-in reference interaction time-stamp
  • Flexibility (enter more or less information)

Sunshine Carter (University of Minnesota-Duluth) came up with using Google Docs as a straightforward solution to the challenge of effectively collecting library usage data. This approach requires no budget and also no assistance of IT staff. It took her about one hour to get the show off the ground (same here when I tried it).

For data collection, I simply created a communal access point via Blogger (by invitation only). A separate “Help” section explains to users the meaning and scope of each tracking variable.


Blogger Screenshot



The interesting bit is to come up with local tracking variables that mean something to your library. The idea is to keep this high-level and straight forward. The more complex the solution, the more time it will take for reference staff to enter data.

Prior to implementation think backwards. Here are some suggestions:
  • What questions about library use do we have?
  • What statistics would help answer those questions?
  • What data would get us those statistics?
  • Carefully customise data collection fields
  • Ensure common data collection/terminology/practice across all library sites/offices

25 May 2012

4th International Conference on Qualitative and Quantitative Methods in Libraries

Just back from a spell at the 4th International Conference on Qualitative and Quantitative Methods in Libraries (22nd - 25th May, Absolute Hotel) in Limerick, where I presented some of the findings of my PhD and chaired a session on technology in libraries.

The QQML conference offered a wide range of topics: digital libraries, information literacy, research methods, staff management, technology, library management, collection policies and historical aspects were just some of the headings. Attendees from over 50 countries enjoyed the sunny weather and listened to more than 250 papers and looked at about 20 posters.

Some of the sessions seemed to have been put together somewhat arbitrarily - not all the papers fitted into the slot. Also, I only found out that I was to chair a session when I read the final programme... Organisational issues aside, all presentations I listened to were of high quality and very interesting. Professional librarians, academics and PhD students shared their findings and introduced new projects running in their organisations.

Although I only attended for one day and the programme was quite packed I managed to talk to a number of colleagues from around the globe. This is always an enjoyable exercise.

The book of abstracts is available online.

Free webinars to promote open access publication across Ireland

NECOBELAC and its partners will deliver two free webinars in Open Access Publication next month:

Webinar 1, (8 June 2012, 11am – 12pm): “Open access publishing: policies, advocacy and best practices”

Webinar 2, (22 June 2012, 11am – 12 pm): “Repositories: management, policies, advocacy and best practices”

To register for Webinar 1, click here

The webinars will consist of a 30 min presentation followed by an opportunity for participants to post questions and comments to the chat room.

As I have been fortunate enough to be involved in NECOBELAC training events recently, I can recommend the above as an excellent (and free!) opportunity to learn more about open access publishing and archiving, and to discuss how to promote it effectively to the research community.