8 Jul 2013

Five useful librarian webinars in July

The summer months tend to create some spare time to learn about various goings-on in the wider library and information management community. I find webinars particularly useful for this as they tend to provide you with tangible and tested ideas that could potentially improve, or even transform, your own professional work context.

At the end of the day, it’s all about improving and adding new services to your library, which in turn increase patron experience translating into happy and engaged library funders.

The forthcoming free-of-charge webinars listed below cover the areas of 3D printing, mobile technology, social media use, IT literacy training, IL assessment and Library marketing.

Take your pick...

3D Printing for Everyone,
Wednesday, 10th July, 9pm - 10pm(Dublin time)
Ed Snajder introduces you to his open source 3D printer built from a kit. He'll talk about his experiences, from assembly and tuning, to modeling and printing.

Library Social Media Use,
Wednesday, 17th July, 9pm - 8pm (Dublin time)
Over half of the world’s 2 billion internet users interact with social media tools to create, share, and exchange information and ideas while online. Libraries are using these tools to market programs and services, and to connect and engage with their communities beyond the library walls. Join us as we explore Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest as examples of tools that are being used successfully by libraries. The webinar will cover how to create, administer, moderate, and leverage your library’s online presence. Some basic security settings for each social media tool will be discussed as well.

TEAL Library Highlights: Technology Training at the Library,
Friday, 19th July, 4:00pm - 5:30pm (Dublin time)
Libraries are on the front lines of digital inclusion and digital literacy efforts across the state. This webinar will feature a panel of Texas library staff from Gilbreath Memorial Library (Winnsboro, TX), Rita and Truett Smith Public Library (Wylie, TX) and the Library at Cedar Creek (Seven Points, TX). Panelists will share their experiences planning and offering computer classes as part of their participation in the Technology Expertise, Access and Learning for all Texans project (TEAL). Is your library thinking about offering classes?- Join us to learn from the experiences of other libraries!

Localize, Mobilize, and Spotlight Your Library Services and Outreach,
Tuesday, 23rd July, 7pm - 8pm (Dublin time)
Libraries play a critical role in their communities that goes beyond their collections, focusing on events, outreach and library as place. In an increasingly digital and mobile world, libraries need new ways to reach out and engage. Now with the new OCLC Library Spotlight program (www.worldcat.org/spotlight), you can set up a dynamic mobile view of your library and dramatically extend its visibility into many popular web services—in just 10 minutes. Learn about this free service, available to all, that will make it easier for your library to be found on the web and through highly trafficked services like Yelp. Hear how one library focused its messaging and engagement through coordinated efforts at a local level to maximize their web presence and reach.

Information Literacy Assessment: What Works? What Doesn’t? (LYRASIS Polite Debate Society),
Friday, 19th July, 6pm - 7.30pm (Dublin time)
During the last Polite Debate Society, we addressed Information literacy from the teaching perspective... How to teach the Hard Stuff (Recording: http://lyrasis.adobeconnect.com/p42slccadgz/).  In part 2 of the series, panelists from the information literacy community will spend 90 minutes discussing key issues in information literacy assessment. The teaching landscape for IL librarians continues to evolve rapidly. Assessment strategies used previously in the traditional classroom environment are challenging, if not impossible to implement in an educational setting where we use both the physical and virtual classroom, where technology dictates our approach to teaching so heavily, and where many deal with the pressure cooker of the "one shot" class.  Still others are learning what kinds of assessment strategies are most effective in the semester long credit bearing information literacy course. In our Polite Debate Society session, our panel will review and critique some common assessment strategies, discuss what works and what doesn't in a variety of settings, and share ideas for best practices in information literacy assessment.

5 Jul 2013

The battle of the library ecosystem

Guest post by Ken Chad

June 2013 – A version of this was published for the JISC LMS Change programme

Looking at the top ten strategic technology trends for 2013, Gartner noted: “The market is undergoing a shift to more integrated systems and ecosystems and away from loosely coupled heterogeneous approaches(1)”. The report goes on to say: “Driving this trend is the user desire for lower cost, simplicity, and more assured security. Driving the trend for vendors the ability to have more control of the solution stack and obtain greater margin in the sale as well as offer a complete solution stack in a controlled environment”. This is not to say the vendor develops and provides all the elements in the ecosystem. Apple is the obvious example here. It provides a platform for the ‘community’ (including Higher Education) to develop content and apps which are nonetheless delivered as part of an ‘ecosystem over which Apple exerts considerable control.

If this is a trend for technology in general, perhaps it is no surprise to see it beginning to be reflected in the library system environment.  For example, we are seeing a new generation of library systems integrating ‘discovery services’, which had previously been ‘decoupled’. Marshall Breeding remarked on this trend at the LITA(2) Top Tech Trends session at the 2012 annual American Library Association (ALA) conference: “As the back-end modernises and becomes more comprehensive itself, and has more hooks into the remote resources […] it reintroduces the opportunity to integrate discovery and back-end automation." As well as the re-integration of discovery services, these new platforms integrate back-end Electronic Resource Management (ERM) systems, which had been separate applications. For example, the ExLibris Alma Library Services Platform replaces both the Aleph library management system and the Verde ERM.

So what is, or might be, encompassed by a library technology ecosystem? In the last century we spoke of ‘stand alone’ library management systems and by the late 90s these systems had become functionally rich with many ‘modules’ to manage different aspects of library management. With the advent of more digital resources, especially electronic journals and the web, things became more complex.  Lorcan Dempsey summed it up in 2007: “One of the main issues facing libraries as they work to create richer user services is the complexity of their systems environment. Reductively, we can think of three classes of systems - (1) the classic ILS [Integrated Library System] focused on 'bought' materials, (2) the emerging systems framework around licensed collections, and (3) potentially several repository systems for 'digital' resources”.

The number of elements or functions covered in such a systems environment – or ‘ecosystem’ – has grown over the years. In addition to the familiar modules of the library management system, the library may be responsible for, and have separate systems to manage, electronic journals and ebooks, reading lists, archives and special collections, local digital collections and the institutional repository for research outputs.


The range of library interest and responsibility has also extended into other areas of Teaching Learning and Research, which involve library-like skills (classification, curation) as well as links to library-managed resources. In some cases the Virtual Learning Environment (VLE) is also the responsibility of the library.  And, as research data gets more attention, some libraries are developing a role in, and acquiring systems for, Research Data Management (RDM).

For the most part the landscape remains, however, one of silos rather than an interconnected, interoperable ‘ecosystem’. This is most obviously seen as users try to discover resources; navigating a number of systems with different search interfaces and methods of description and classification. Even such a basic element as a ‘name’ may appear differently in the library catalogue and institutional repository.

Some libraries have managed to bring a number of these silos together under a unified discovery service umbrella but with only partial success. Harmonising metadata to provide a single central index across such diverse systems and, from a vendor’s point of view, across many institutions is not a trivial task. Jisc recently described the problem in the following way: “Over the years various metadata schemas and models have emerged, but clarity on the best metadata strategy to adopt or how to achieve interoperability between scholarly systems has been a hard nut to crack.”(3) It is not yet clear whether ‘more integrated systems and ecosystems’ or ‘loosely coupled heterogeneous approaches’ will win out; as we have seen, Gartner suggests the former.

So as earlier generations of library management systems gradually encompass more and more ‘modules’ (circulation, cataloguing, acquisitions, serials, OPAC, etc), will a coherent ecosystem develop to knit together the now extended landscape of system silos? The trend seems to be that way but it is at a very early stage.

As noted above, library resource management and discovery is becoming ‘unified’ across both print and electronic (primarily e-journal articles) resources. The manifestation of this is a number of next generation ‘library services platforms’. Vendors clearly have ambitions to extend the ecosystem to digital repositories and digital archives – for example, ExLibris positions their ‘Rosetta’ product in this way (4). However, progress remains slow and each ‘silo’ still retains distinct approaches to metadata and, perhaps inevitably, to workflows. The cross-domain Europeana project has mandated ‘semantic elements’ (5) (Dublin Core based) to bring some order to the field. The problem is recognised outside libraries, with Google and other search services cooperating on a common metadata ‘schema’ (6) that is gaining attention in the library domain. These do represent progress but in Jisc's view: “The use of schemas and also vocabularies associated with particular fields (restricted set of keywords/classifications) has been patchy at best”.

As institutions work together and share library systems (7), the need for harmonisation of data and workflows increases. As technology moves to ‘the cloud’ and as libraries begin to share common cloud-based 'multi-tenant' library services platforms, the opportunity for a more integrated library ecosystem may grow. Higher Education is naturally wary of giving vendors 'control of the solution stack’ so may continue to value a ‘loosely coupled’ approach, perhaps containing strong elements of open source software and ‘above-campus’ community services. But in hard economic times, if a vendor-controlled integrated ecosystem can deliver “lower cost, simplicity, and more assured security”, as suggested  by Gartner above, it may prove very attractive.

References:
(1) Gartner Identifies the Top 10 Strategic Technology Trends for 2013. Analysts Examine Top Industry Trends at Gartner Symposium/ITxpo, October 21-25 in Orlando’. Press Release. 23 October 2012
http://www.gartner.com/newsroom/id/2209615

(2) Library IT Association, a division of ALA

(3) 'Tracking research across the fields'. By Balviar Notay and Neil Jacobs. Research Information. 7 March 2013

(4) See Europeana ‘Technical Requirements' http://www.exlibrisgroup.com/category/RosettaOverview

(5) See Europeana ‘Technical Requirements' http://pro.europeana.eu/technical-requirements

(6) ‘Schema.org is an initiative launched on 2 June 2011 by Bing, Google and Yahoo! ...to “create and support a common set of schemas for structured data markup on web pages.’ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schema.org

(7) HE institutions in both Wales and Scotland are investigating shared systems. See the JISC Library Systems programme http://www.jisc.ac.uk/whatwedo/programmes/di_informationandlibraries/emergingopportunities/librarysystems.aspx

2 Jul 2013

A First Look at Data Citation

Thomson Reuters' Journal Citation Reports, Incites and Science Citation Index have (rightly or wrongly) become landmark products in the bibiometrics landscape. With data management one of the hottest topics in scholarly communications at the moment, TR were unsurprisingly one of the first to move into the data citation space as well.

The Data Citation Index was launched in November 2012 and is designed to quantify the impact and reuse of research data. This is still quite a new area for many of us, and a recent working paper by Torres-Salinas et al. looks at the coverage of the DCI in terms of disciplines, document types and repositories. The authors' analysis estimates that:

  • 80% of the records included in the index are classified as Science, 18% as Social Sciences and 2% as Humanities & Arts records. Engineering & Technology is almost non-existent, accounting for less than 0.1% of the total records.
  • The DCI uses three document types. There are 96 data repositories, and the predominant typology is the data set which is 94% of the entire database. The third document type, data studies, comprise around 6% of the total records included in the index.
  • 64 of the 96 repositories included in the index contain at least 100 records. However, there is a very high concentration across just four repositories, which together account for 75% of all records from repositories in the DCI: Gene Expression Omnibus, UniProt Knowledgebase, PANGAEA and U.S. Census Bureau TIGER/Line Shapefiles.
As it is still early days for open data, data sets and data repositories, it will be interesting to see if and how these trends change over time.
Source: http://knowledgeblog.org/117

28 Jun 2013

Celebrating Success: An Open Day for Library and Information Workers

Guest post by Helen Kielt (@helenkielt), Libraries NI

On Wednesday 26 June 2013 CILIP Ireland and Career Development Group (NI Division) hosted ‘Celebrating Success’, an event which took place in the trendy Titanic Quarter Campus of Belfast Metropolitan College. The programme was themed around recognising achievements and encouraging the continuing development of library and information workers in a variety of sectors. Members and non-members were invited to meet, network and hear from knowledgeable speakers on topics relating to promoting skills and expertise within the information professions.

Recognising Professional Skills and Knowledge

Simon Edwards, Director of Professional Services at CILIP, spoke about gaining recognition for professional skills and gave an overview of the CILIP Professional Knowledge and Skills Base (PKSB). The PKSB is a framework designed to help members to identify and monitor a broad range of professional skills. As a self-assessment tool it can be used to identify gaps in skills and experience, with a view to expanding expertise and developing knowledge in a range of contexts. Simon discussed making professional registration more relevant, accessible and attractive. Routes such as Certification and Chartership are important pathways for exploring continued professional development. A lot of attention has been given in recent times to CILIP rebranding and Simon gave an update on this, advocating member’s choice and speaking of change as an opportunity to move forward refocused on ethos and ambition.

Recognising Research, Study and On-going Learning

Dr Jessica Bates (@Jessica_Bates), Lecturer in Library and Information Management at the University of Ulster, spoke about the value of research for library and information services. Like Simon, Jessica emphasised the importance of professional knowledge and skills being balanced by professional practice and reflection. As Jessica said, ‘if the role of the librarian is to enable learning, we need also to progress our own learning and development’. Jessica alluded to the building blocks of success such as learning from others, study and evidence based practice. There are many routes to professional success and reading is key to developing professionally. Keeping up to date with journals and publications such as CILIP Update are important ways to engage with research and learn about best practice.

Jessica was joined by present and former students of the Library and Information Management course at UU; Geraldine Delaney, Sarah Smyth, and Peter Wright - fitting advocates for the information profession and lifelong learning. Jessica talked about celebrating the success of students and graduates, both in terms of their individual achievements and their role in raising the status of information professionals in Northern Ireland. Sarah Smyth shared her success in contributing to an emerging body of local research evidence, through her master’s study of eBook usage among higher education students in Northern Ireland. PhD student Peter Wright who is currently researching the use of tablets in post-primary schools, talked about his own route to the profession and the role of CILIP Chartership in introducing ways of developing both the library professional and the library. I was delighted that my fellow classmate Geraldine Delaney shared expertise from her career and academic life, from working on a project restocking libraries in post-revolution Romania to becoming an informed advocate of library practice through postgraduate study.

Recognising Possibilities

It is a worthy exercise to look at the balance of our skills, particularly given the diverse roles encompassed by ‘information professions’ and the scarcity of the term ‘librarian’ in job listings. This was a common thread among the speakers and interestingly, Sarah Smyth shared in her presentation an illustration of this emerging reality via the blog post by Mia Breitkopf, ‘61 Non-Librarian Jobs for LIS Grads’. There is no ‘one size fits all’ and we are now experiencing the information profession at its most diverse. We need to be equipped for professional practice in all its guises-libraries and library related roles are changing at a rate analogous to the chicken-and-egg scenario.

What emerged most for me from this event is not just celebrating success but the journey towards it. Simon referred to a library and information career path as a visual equivalent of the London Underground map - there are so many destinations, junctions and opportunities to re-route that no two professionals’ paths could possibly be the same. Benefits of attending an event like this include networking with a pool of people from different information professions. A strange sense of like-mindedness amongst diversity, regional networking events can cement a feeling of support rather than competition within the information community. Whatever course/membership/professional recognition route you choose, relish the possibilities on your path of development.


27 Jun 2013

Semantic Interoperability Conference (SEMIC) 2013

Guest post by Betty Maguire, MLIS Graduate, UCD

The Semantic Interoperability Conference was held on June 21 this year at The Croke Park Conference Centre, Dublin. It was a most interesting conference, the main theme of which was Achieving Interoperability Through Reuse. Conference Speakers presented case studies on many topics including the topic of Open standards for e-Government and the evolution of eGov Core Vocabularies, presented by Phil Archer of W3C, the Semantic Operability of Basic Data in the Italian Public Sector, presented by Giorgio Lodi of Agenzia per L’Italia Digitale- AGgID and publishing and linking government data.

Active discussions were held on the subjects of linked data and core vocabularies. One conference speaker, Leda Bargiotti of the Publications Office of the EU introduced the topic of DCAT Application Profile, a specification for describing public sector datasets in Europe. The specification is based on the Data Catalogue vocabulary.

The use of the semantic web was also discussed in the context of maintaining the quality of EU statistics. In his paper entitled ‘Maintaining the Quality of EU Statistics While Enabling Re-Use’, Marco Pellegrino of Eurostat suggested that semantically linked data could lead to a standardization of statistical data and faster provision of more accurate statistical information. Pellegrino also made reference to RDF vocabularies, linked data and RDF Data Cube Vocabulary based on SDMX. He highlighted several issues to consider if updating a statistical database in RDF format, including a possible loss of control of ownership of the statistical data, possible conflicting statistical figures occurring when the database is updated in RDF, and a broader definition of raw or confidential data held by the body updating the database in RDF than the body processing the statistical data.

Jochen Hummel and Gudrún Magnúsdóttir of ESTeam AB presented a case study of the use of the semantics and language technology in TMClass to harmonise trademark registrations. The organizational benefits of making the European Trademark System interoperable with semantics include the seamless and borderless intellectual property registration of a trademark in any of the official languages of the EU. A commercial benefit of this interoperability is that an individual’s or organization’s trademark can be described in their native language.

Finally, Richard Cyganiak of the Digital Enterprise Research Institute (DERI) at NUI Galway spoke about a project to publish and link government data using the Open Data Pipeline (ODP), a web based publishing platform. Richard discussed how input data, such as .csv or excel files, was mapped onto ODP using D2RQ, a database-to-RDF mapping tool.

Perhaps the key message put across from the case studies presented at the conference was that semantic interoperability between public sector datasets and datasets within EU institutions can facilitate the provision of access to cross-border EU datasets, access to EU policy and data sharing.

25 Jun 2013

Are e-books any of our business?

Guest Post by Jack Hyland, Assistant Librarian, DCU (@jackwhyland)


Image: Johan Larsson
If you haven’t noticed, higher education libraries are stuck in a long and complicated e-books crisis. It’s very different from the serials crisis, with its clear battle lines drawn between Open Access evangelists tilting at predatory publishers, but a crisis that could leave both libraries and traditional publishers side-lined as redundant middle men.

Higher education e-books are nothing like the slick and highly successful e-book Kindle model. They’re clunky DRM-laden PDFs, sold from publisher to aggregator to library with a series of constantly changing business models. They’re just about tolerable for users to read on a PC screen but close to useless on any other device (phone? Tablet? Good luck trying). But students seem to be OK with them, preferring reading a bad online version for free rather than spending €50-€70 on their own print copy. The publishers know this, and they’re terrified. They thought a dual model of print and online was sustainable but its killing them, and they’re backing out: either refusing to sell e-versions to libraries or hiking the prices and restricting the access terms to make them less attractive.

So where are we going? Nobody knows, but there have been some interesting suggestions, such as a Spotify for e-books. Here’s what I think – in five years, libraries will have no role in handling the Big Undergrad Textbook – venerable beasts like Sociology by Giddens. If publishers don’t adapt and start selling online very widely and very cheaply, someone else will. The Big Textbooks are easy kill for ambitious startups, people like Flatworld Knowledge and  OpenStax, who provide very readable access to more generic undergrad content across all platforms for free or close-to-free. Students will soon access this content direct – there’s no need for libraries here.

With most other book content, like more specialised textbooks, supplementary readings and research monographs, I think we’re on safer ground. A lot needs to change here – publishers needs to provide better interfaces and better business models and we libraries need  to be willing to negotiate a fair  price for this. But can publishers survive on all these titles with much smaller demand, without the Big Textbook cash cows? I just don’t know. Will we also see the rise in the university press for e-books, or radical redefinitions of what we think of as books? Perhaps, but maybe not in the short term.

While we’re slowly getting there with the e-textbook, one medium that’s crying out for online delivery is the dusty, discipline-specific reference book. Students should, but don’t use them  - (mention of them in my classes meets blank-faced silence – worse than PowerPoint slides of Boolean Venn diagrams). But publishers don’t know what to do with them online.  A massive, once-off purchase? An annual subscription? In any attempts I’ve made to move online with them, publishers have replied with some jaw-dropping ten-fold price increases from the print version. And even if I went for it, would students use them instead of Wikpedia? I’m not sure.

We shouldn’t waste a good crisis. So what can librarians do, short of becoming publishers ourselves? One area we need to do better in is liaison with lecturers in sourcing texts. Instead of taking the lecturers title request and making guesstimates on projected demand (3 e-book copies, 5 short loan print copies etc.), we need to work with them to try to figure out how to get  (1) the best quality texts at (2) reasonable prices and (3) all with 24/7 access across all platforms for all students and (4) trying to do all this across all modules. It’s a very tall order, but if should be very interesting seeing if we can do it.

*Thanks to my colleagues Miriam Corcoran and Mary Kiely for their advice in researching this.